Clearances of the ANSI / IEEE set
The ANSI / IEEE set takes its yard clearances from RUS Bulletin 1724E-300 Table 4-7, by the level's basic lightning impulse insulation level (BIL). It adds the National Electrical Safety Code (NESC), 2007 edition, for the live parts above the surfaces where people stand and for the fence.
1The row of a level
A level takes the row of RUS Bulletin 1724E-300 Table 4-7 with the smallest standard BIL at or above the level's BIL, from IEEE C37.04-2018 Table 6 (Insulation levels, The ANSI / IEEE set). Two rows list a BIL of 1050 kVp, and a level below 345 kV takes the 230 kV one. The row's values hold for altitudes up to 1000 m (Table 4-7, note 1).
The design reads three clearances from the row:
- phase to earth: the minimum distance from rigid conductors to grounded parts
- phase to phase: the minimum metal-to-metal distance of rigid conductors
- ground: the minimum height of bare overhead conductors above grade for personal safety
The yard's phase spacing is the larger of the row's rigid-bus spacing and the spacing of Table 4-8 for side-break or horizontal-break disconnect switches, since the yard's isolators are horizontal centre-break. Where Table 4-8 lists no switch spacing (the 345 kV row at 1300 kVp), the largest spacing of the rows below applies. The bases of the insulators and bushings of energized equipment are at least 2.44 m above the top of a foundation (Table 4-7, note 3).
This set has no sectional clearance. The NESC rules below take its place. The clearances of the set's levels are in the table.
| Level | BIL | Phase to earth | Phase to phase | Ground | Phase spacing | NESC vertical clearance | NESC fence clearance R |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 69 kV | 350 kVp | 0.635 m | 0.787 m | 3.35 m | 1.83 m | 3.17 m | 3.54 m |
| 115 kV | 550 kVp | 1.07 m | 1.35 m | 3.66 m | 2.74 m | 3.53 m | 3.96 m |
| 138 kV | 650 kVp | 1.27 m | 1.6 m | 3.96 m | 3.35 m | 3.71 m | 4.18 m |
| 161 kV | 750 kVp | 1.47 m | 1.83 m | 4.27 m | 3.96 m | 3.91 m | 4.36 m |
| 230 kV | 900 kVp | 1.8 m | 2.26 m | 4.57 m | 4.87 m | 4.19 m | 4.69 m |
| 345 kV | 1300 kVp | 2.64 m | 3.02 m | 5.49 m | 5.5 m | 5.23 m | 5.58 m |
| 34.5 kV collector bus | 200 kVp | 0.33 m | 0.457 m | 3.05 m | 1.22 m | 2.90 m | 3.23 m |
2The NESC 2007 clearances
NESC 2007 Rule 124A1 sets the clearance of unguarded live parts above a surface where people stand, by Table 124-1. The design takes Column 2, the vertical clearance, at the smallest listed BIL at or above the level's. Part A applies up to a maximum design voltage of 242 kV, and Part C above 242 kV.
Part B of Table 124-1 gives clearances by the switching-surge factor, and applies too where the switching-surge factor of the network is known. The design does not take it. The vertical clearance is checked against the equipment level of the high-voltage (HV) yard and of an outdoor collector bus.
Rule 124A3 keeps the bottom of insulators at least 2.6 m above grade, and the yard takes it as its insulator base. Rule 110A1 asks for a fence of at least 2.13 m overall, and the yard's fence is 2.44 m high.
Rule 110A2 keeps the live parts outside the safety clearance zone of the fence. The zone's dimension R comes from Table 110-1 by the BIL and is measured from the fence at 1.5 m above grade. The design makes two checks of it:
- the fence offset and the peripheral road, between the fence and the nearest live part, are at least R
- the gantry beam, where the line conductors cross the fence, is at least R above that point
3Altitude
Above 1000 m, the design derates the BIL of the rows by the factor of RUS Bulletin 1724E-300 Table 4-3, for the first listed altitude at or above the site. It takes the row with the smallest standard BIL whose derated value is at or above the level's BIL. That row's clearances apply, and the yard's geometry grows to suit them.
The level's own BIL is not changed, and neither are the other insulation levels (Insulation levels, Altitude). Table 4-3 ends at 6000 m, and the design refuses a site above it. It also refuses a level whose row would need a BIL above 1300 kVp, the last row of Table 4-7.
A strung jumper over a bus is a nonrigid conductor. The design increases the metal-to-metal clearance by 50 % for it, in its level and in its check.
Given a 115 kV level with a BIL of 550 kVp, at a site altitude of 2400 m. Table 4-3 gives the factor = 0.86 there.
The level's own row derated: = 473 kVp, which is below the level's 550 kVp.
The next standard BIL derated: = 559 kVp, which is at or above the level's 550 kVp.
Clearances of the 650 kVp row, against those of the 550 kVp row:
| Clearance | Up to 1000 m | At 2400 m |
|---|---|---|
| Phase to earth | 1.07 m | 1.27 m |
| Phase to phase | 1.35 m | 1.6 m |
| Ground | 3.66 m | 3.96 m |
Result At 2400 m the 115 kV level takes the clearances of the 650 kVp row, while its equipment stays rated at 550 kVp.
Given a new 230 kV project of the ANSI / IEEE set with the level's defaults: a BIL of 900 kVp, a one-and-a-half breaker scheme and a site altitude of 500 m. The yard takes the 900 kVp row.
| Check | Clearance | Provided | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Phase spacing, phase to phase | 2.26 m | 4.90 m | Pass |
| Phase spacing, bus and switch spacing | 4.87 m | 4.90 m | Pass |
| Outer phase to the bay edge, phase to earth | 1.80 m | 5.10 m | Pass |
| Equipment level, ground | 4.57 m | 5.00 m | Pass |
| Equipment level, NESC vertical clearance | 4.19 m | 5.00 m | Pass |
| Main bus above the equipment, phase to phase | 2.26 m | 3.50 m | Pass |
| Strung jumper above the main bus, phase to phase increased for a nonrigid conductor | 3.39 m | 4.39 m | Pass |
| Live parts to the fence, NESC R | 4.69 m | 7.00 m | Pass |
| Line over the fence, NESC R | 4.69 m | 14.50 m | Pass |
Result The yard passes the checks above. The nearest to its limit is the phase spacing against the bus and switch spacing.
[1]RUS Bulletin 1724E-300, Design Guide for Rural Substations.
[2]ANSI C2-2007, National Electrical Safety Code.
[3]IEEE C37.04-2018, IEEE Standard for Ratings and Requirements for AC High-Voltage Circuit Breakers.